In a nod to The Wizard of Oz, Kristy McNichol (Little Darlings) plays a dorky young woman who passes out and dreams of being an 18th century damsel in love with a handsome buccaneer, played by Christopher Atkins (The Blue Lagoon).
Reaction & Thoughts:
Gilbert & Sullivan filtered through Mel Brooks’s sensibilities. This musical spoof of pirate movies is one of the few ’80s movies that has always eluded me. It’s loosely based on The Pirates of Penzance, and it mixes the operetta’s famous soundtrack with pop songs, performed (well enough) by McNichol and Atkins. There are lots of movie references too.
Unfortunately, The Pirate Movie doesn’t work — it was a notorious critical disaster. Yes, this is really bad. It’s not even a case of ‘so bad, it’s good’ — it’s just plain awful. Director Ken Annakin (Those Magnificent Men in their Flying Machines), whom I tend to like, does a terrible job mixing elements from the classic operetta with modern songs and slapstick. I enjoyed the references to the other movies — e.g. The Pink Panther, Star Wars, Raiders of the Lost Ark — but these funny nuggets aren’t able to save the movie.
You can’t force me to say anything negative about McNichol, one of my childhood crushes. She is a really good actress. McNichol tries, but she’s surrounded by mediocrity. Atkins did have a surprising billboard hit with the song “How Can I Live Without Her?,” written by Sue Shifrin and Terry Britten.
Conclusions & Final Thoughts:
The Pirate Movie earns its reputation as one of the worst musicals ever made. That being said, the movie has its defenders. Lots of people who saw it on cable TV during their childhood seem to have some affection for it. What can you say to those viewers? Nostalgia is a powerful thing (I’m also guilty of defending the indefensible). As I always say, you be the judge, but don’t say I didn’t warn you! Color, 98 minutes, Rated PG.