The Judge and Jake Wyler (1972, TV-Movie)


An eccentric ex-judge (Bette Davis) and a cynical parolee (Doug McClure, The Land That Time Forgot) join forces to solve the murder of a wealthy man.

Reaction & Thoughts:

“Jake… you have all the instincts of a kamikaze pilot!”

The Judge and Jake Wyler is one of the many TV pilots Bette Davis made during her long career in showbiz. As on previous occasions, the pilot wasn’t picked up by the Network. While she never made much fuss about past rejections, this time around Davis was particularly angry with how things turned out.

Produced by NBC Universal Television and directed by David Lowell Rich (A Family Upside Down and The Concorde: Airport ’79), The Judge and Jake Wyler was conceived by Richard Levinson and William Link, the men behind many hit TV series, including Columbo, Mannix and Murder, She Wrote. For whatever reason, the powers that be decided against Levinson and Link’s proposal.

With TV pilots being nothing more than a proof of concept, it was no surprise to me that The Judge and Jake Wyler feels incomplete. But I thought it was a fine idea for a weekly series. I’m assuming that someone upstairs decided that there wasn’t room for yet another TV series about private detectives. Cannon, Kojack, McMillan & Wife, Banacek, McCloud, etc., the 1970s was clearly the decade of TV sleuths.

As was customary with rejected TV pilots, the network added footage to convert the 50-minute pilot into a feature-length film (it debuted as NBC’s TV-Movie-of-the-Week), and Davis complained that the extra material diminished the importance of her character. I have a feeling that she didn’t see the final product because I can honestly say that I didn’t see any signs of padding — Davis remains the beating heart of the movie.

Anyhow, the cast is very good. Davis gives a nicely relaxed performance as the judge-turned-private-detective who can’t stand the smell of cigarettes! Doug McClure, who plays the judge’s partner-in-crime, has great chemistry with Davis. Joan Van Ark (TV’s Knots Landing) plays a troubled heiress, Lou Jacobi (Irma La Deuce) is a police detective and Kent Smith (Cat People) has a cameo as Van Ark’s father.

Conclusions & Final Thoughts:

More than anything else, The Judge and Jake Wyler is an unremarkable but fun curiosity. Mostly for fans of old TV series like Barnaby Jones and Bette Davis devotees. The film is available on YouTube. Followed by a semi-sequel titled Partners in Crime with Oscar-winning actress Lee Grant (In the Heat of the Night) as the judge and Lou Antonio (Cool Hand Luke) as the ex-convict. Color, 91 minutes, Not Rated.

9 responses to “The Judge and Jake Wyler (1972, TV-Movie)

  1. It’s always a shame when something doesn’t get picked up by a network. Especially when it has a lot of potential. One often has to wonder in general why some shows get renewed with so many seasons, and other’s fail to even get out of the starting blocks.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Wow!! You pulled this one out of a hat. I need to search this one out.

    Speaking of actors with lost opportunities: I was just reading that Tim Matheson — who rocks in everything he does — was down to the wire for the role of Elliot Stabler on Law and Order: SVU. I would have enjoyed seeing Tim on a long-running series. No actor could be more deserving. He would have been a great Stabler.

    As for Bette Davis: Bigas Luna had her slated for 1987’s Anquish. And if you’ve seen that crazy flick, you’ll agree that, while Zelda Rubenstein was on-point, we’d would have loved Bette in the role of Mother Pressman — going on and on about snails and eyeballs. (She did the Whales of August with Vincent Price, instead.)

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s