A struggling actress (Mary Steenburgen, Melvin and Howard) is asked to do a screen test at an isolated mansion, but this isn’t what it looks like.
Reaction & Thoughts:
From filmmaker Arthur Penn, the man behind such well-regarded classics The Miracle Worker (1962) and Bonnie and Clyde (1967), comes this irresistibly daffy thriller — Dead of Winter is low on logic, but high on amusingly goofy plot twists.
This is a loose remake of Joseph H. Lewis’s nifty B-movie My Name Is Julia Ross (1945). Dead of Winter has very little in common with the 1940s film — it’s a completely different story — and while Lewis’s movie is much better than Penn’s, the original isn’t half as entertaining as the remake.
Does that make any sense? Let me explain. This is one of those movies that falls under the category of “so silly, it’s good.” The script — by Marc Shmuger and Mark Malone — has more plot holes that I was able to count. Dead of Winter becomes more and more implausible with each passing scene.
I didn’t buy a single moment in the film and yet I was entertained all the same. Dead of Winter is an absurd, (unintentionally?) hilarious, campy thriller that has always managed to tickle me to death! Director Penn’s polished direction and the excellent work of the actors help you suspend disbelief.
Mary Steenburgen has a field day — she plays three different roles. Because Steenburgen isn’t the kind of actor you expect to see ham it up, I was kinda mesmerized by her attempts to do what doesn’t come natural to her (who the heck she thinks she is? Bette Davis? Joan Crawford?). She’s a character actress who seizes a rare opportunity to do a star turn and that’s interesting in itself.
Steenburgen gets some fierce competition from her two main co-stars. Roddy McDowall (Planet of the Apes) and Jan Rubes (Witness) play the two bad guys and they are both excellent. McDowall, in particular, is a complete delight as he tries to create his own version of Norman Bates. All three actors are hell-bent on stealing scenes, so it is a lot of fun to see them all turn up the volume.
Conclusions & Final Thoughts:
Dead of Winter is bad in a fun way. There is something appealing about a retro-thriller that throws common sense out of the window — the whole thing is deliciously bonkers! An ideal late night snack! Color, 97 minutes, Rated R.