Eve Harrington (Anne Baxter, The Razord’s Edge), the self-proclaimed #1 fan of theater legend Margo Channing (Bette Davis), ingratiates herself into the famous and temperamental thespian’s inner circle of friends and colleagues. However, unbeknownst to most of them, Margo included, Eve has an agenda of her own: the young woman would do anything, I mean anything, to become as famous as her idol.
Reaction & Thoughts:
One of those films that don’t need an introduction. Joseph L. Mankiewicz’s All About Eve is simply put an American classic. The film, in my humble opinion, contains the best screenplay ever written in Hollywood. The cast is extraordinary too. There isn’t a single false note in the entire movie — this is as perfect as cinema can be.
I’m not even going to attempt to explain why All About Eve is so great. I’m just going to try to articulate why I like it so much.
Firstly, I just love Makewicz’z (A Letter to Three Wives) witty, intelligent script. The narrative, which is loosely based on Mary Orr’s Cosmopolitan Magazine short story (Orr’s story was inspired by the real-life relationship between German Actress Elisabeth Bergner and her assistant), is brilliantly constructed. The script also has more quotable lines per minute than any other film in history. Of course, no one, not even the literate people of the theater, talks like that. But the actors make all those lines sound natural, believable.
More important, All About Eve demonstrates that in a predominantly visual medium like cinema dialogue can be a force to be reckoned with. Scenes are staged without much glitter — you barely notice the camera work — and the emphasis is on character development. And each character has a specific function in the movie, which is why I think the movie never ceases to be interesting, engaging, and entertaining.
Finally, the film has a top-notch cast, right down to the smallest roles. It’s now hard to believe that most of the actors were second/third choices.
Anne Baxter does a diabolically good job in the title character. George Sanders’s (The Picture of Dorian Gray) cynical critic Addison DeWitt (“I am a critic – as essential to the theater as ants to a picnic”) is one of cinema’s most memorable villains. Gary Merrill (Twelve O’Clock High) has great chemistry with Davis. Celeste Holm (Gentleman’s Agreement) adds a touch of class to the film as Margo’s best friend. Even a lightweight like Hugh Marlowe (The Day the Earth Stood Still) delivers the goods as playwright Lloyd Richards.
Thelma Ritter (Rear Window), who plays Margo’s plain-spoken assistant, Birdie, has some of the funniest lines. If I have a complaint is that Ritter’s character disappears halfway through the movie — the second half could have benefited from Birdie’s testy observations. Marilyn Monroe (Bus Stop) has only two scenes, but she literally glows! (not an essay thing to do when you are in the same scene with Davis and Sanders!). And Barbara Bates (Cheaper by the Dozen) was lucky enough to have the ending all by herself.
Towering over all of them is Bette Davis. She always claimed that she and Margo Channing had very little in common, but I’m not sure that’s entirely true. Maybe she’s right, I don’t know, but Margo is exactly how I perceived Davis to be in real life. Anyhow, Davis does a superb job letting you see the human side of a larger-than-life theater personality. Even when she behaves badly (“infants behave the way I do, you know – they carry on and misbehave – they’d get drunk if they knew how”), you are always in Margo’s corner.
Alfred Newman’s (How the West Was Won and Airport) spirited music score and Edith Head’s (Sunset Boulevard and To Catch a Thief) memorable gowns are two more things in the movie that deserve praise.
Conclusions & Final Thoughts:
As I said before, All About Eve has many great lines (my personal favorite is: “I’ll admit I may have seen better days, but I’m still not to be had for the price of a cocktail, like a salted peanut”), fantastic acting, and excellent production values. It’s one of those movies I never get tired of watching. It has a powerful, memorable ending — in one short, dialogueless scene Mankiewicz summarizes what this film is all about. All About Eve easily stands with the greatest films in history. B&W, 138 minutes, Not Rated.