The Pride of the Yankees (1942)

The Pride of the Yankees (1942)


Henry “Lou” Gehrig (Gary Cooper, High Noon), the only son of poor German immigrants, dreams about playing Baseball. After joining the Yankees in New York, Gehrig soon becomes the number one player, even managing to eclipse the team’s most famous player, Babe Ruth. Unfortunately as he finds happiness in and out the Baseball field, Gehrig becomes ill with the disease that will later carry his name.

Reaction & Thoughts:

“Today, I consider myself the luckiest man on the face of the Earth”

For many sports fans baseball is a sacred event that shows human beings at their finest. Some of you may even go so far as to say that there is something magical about the competitive nature of the aforementioned sport event.

For reasons that are unknown to me, I have never been able to see the larger-than-life qualities that most people attribute to baseball. However, I have literally fallen in love with various films that deal one way or the other with the world of baseball.

The Bad News Bears (1976)The Natural (1984), and Field of Dreams (1989) are good examples of movies about baseball that I treasure, despite my obvious disdain for the actual sport. However, my favorite baseball film is The Pride of the Yankees, a marvelous biography about the famous Yankee legend Lou “The Iron Man” Gehrig.

The movie avoids the temptation of exploiting the film’s sport angle, concentrating instead in telling a remarkably powerful personal drama. The poignant relationship between Gehrig and his wife, Eleanor (Teresa Wright, The Shadow of A Doubt) is the main focus of the film. Director and Sam Wood (For Whom the Bell Tolls) and cameraman Rudolph Mate (Dodsworth) wisely use many close-ups, successfully keeping a certain intimacy between the characters and the audience.

The film does recreate most of Gehrig’s triumphs on the diamond field, but one should not overlook the finery displayed in the quieter, intimate moments. This nice balance between these two contrasting approaches is what makes the film such a rewarding experience, especially for non-sports fans. This is a Hollywood so the movie plays with facts, but The Pride of the Yankees stays true to the spirit of Gehrig’s remarkable story.

Gary Cooper achieved his dead on performance by carefully studying newsreels of the famous Yankee player. Although Cooper is really too old for the role, he becomes Gehrig right before our eyes. Cooper’s recreation of Gehrig’s famous farewell speech at the Yankee stadium is by now part of the American film folklore, one of cinema’s most moving sequences — you’ll need a box of tissues!

Wright is terrific as Mrs. Gehrig. If Cooper was too old, Wright was a bit too young. It really doesn’t matter — you respond emotionally to the movie because you believe they are the real thing. The cast also includes scene stealers Walter Brennan (My Darling Clementine) and Dan Duryea (The Little Foxes) as a pair of sportswriters. Special guest appearances by baseball luminaries Babe Ruth, Bill Dickey, Bill Stern, Bob Meusel, and Mark Koenig as themselves.

The musical score is mostly composed of variations of the famous tune “Take Me Out to the Ball Game.” Producer Samuel Goldwyn was so concerned about people rejecting a sports film that he decided to add an Irving Berlin song, “Always,” to the movie and went as far as to ask then popular dance duo Veloz & Yolanda to appear in the film. I get what he was trying to do, but this is the only section in the film that feels unnecessary.

The impressive sets were designed by famed art-director William Cameron Menzies (Gone with the Wind). Kudos to editor Daniel Mandell (Wuthering Heights) and the visual effects team for tricking the viewer into believing that right-handed Cooper was a southpaw — shrewd editing and undetectable technical wizardry (the image was flipped) helped create the necessary illusion.

Conclusions & Final Thoughts:

The Pride of the Yankees was nominated for 11 Academy Awards, including one for Best Picture. At the time the film was released, many proclaimed The Pride of the Yankees as one of the best sports movies ever made. I’m not sure if I want to argue against that statement. Certainly I would not argue with anyone about its excellence — it’s a really good movie about a really good person. I would like to add that the film also works as a touching love story. B&W, 127 minutes, Not Rated.

8 responses to “The Pride of the Yankees (1942)

  1. Eric, here you and I are diametrically opposed. I LOVE baseball and watch it every day! Go Nationals! My ex-husband was a die-hard Yankees fan and for a decade, I bathed in his worshiping of his team. Lou Gehrig and Murderer’s Row, memorizing the retired numbers, attending countless Old Yankee Stadium games was a major part of my 20s.
    It’s a fine movie. I love Gary Cooper in this and the marriage chemistry between Cooper and Wright. What has always impressed me was how similar the actor and the man he played was. Nice post!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I have a cousin who is exactly the same – she doesn’t care for sports, but loves sports movies. My dad is the opposite. He loves sports, but doesn’t care for sports movies. He says there’s no tension – in a live game, you really don’t know who is going to win.

    I’m sort of in the middle – I like both. Well, I really like baseball movies rather than sports movies in general. But I so agree – this one is really special! It’s hard to imagine anyone else in the role but Gary Cooper.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Ha! I’m opposite to your dad. I think good sports movies remove the dull bits and create irresistible melodrama. Example: I love The Natural (1984) because it has nothing to do with reality; it’s like an adult fairy tale. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s