Star Trek (The Original Series): The Cage (Unaired Pilot)

Star Trek (TV Series): "The Cage" (Unaired Pilot)


UFP’s (United Federation of Planets) spaceship USS Enterprise, commanded by Captain Christopher Pike (Jeffrey Hunter, The Searchers), answers a distress call from the mysterious planet Talos IV. Once on the planet, the crew finds a group of scientists who were reported missing years ago. However, things aren’t as they appear to be.

Reaction & Thoughts:

“We’re not here, neither of us. We’re in a menagerie, a cage.”

We all know the story. After NBC green-lighted Gene Roddenberry’s “wagon-to-the-stars” idea, the producer submitted a few scripts for the approval of the top brass. The studio picked one, but after watching the final product, they had second thoughts. “Too cerebral” and “not enough action” were the main complaints. Interestingly, the TV executives blamed themselves — that’s a first! — for selecting the wrong script, and they allowed Roddenberry to produce a second pilot and the rest is history.

The unused pilot was eventually re-edited into one of the show’s most popular episodes, The Menagerie. Thankfully, the original pilot has survived and we all can judge with our own eyes the pros and cons of the first voyage of the starship Enterprise. My first impression is of disbelief; this “reject” is not only quite good, but also provides viewers with a fascinating window into a cultural phenomenon in its infancy.

The Cage is gutsy and visionary. From a mixed-gender, mixed-race crew to innovative sets and visual effects, the show is a trailblazer in every sense of the word. In the tradition of Tolkien, producer Roddenberry managed to create a universe from the ground up, not an easy task by any means. Unlike modern science fiction shows, the emphasis is on story and characters. The visuals enhance rather than distract from the storyline.

Some elements didn’t survive the second pilot (Season One’s third episode, Where No Man Has Gone Before). The network vehemently objected to the humorless, all-business second-in-command Number One, played by Majel “Mrs. Roddenberry” Barrett. They couldn’t accept the idea of a cold-blooded woman so Roddenberry relented.

The producer was also forced to get rid of John Hoyt (When Worlds Collide), who plays the ship’s doctor (he’s a bit too old). But Roddenberry would not let go of Spock, a character TV executives found unappealing. He insisted that an alien aboard the ship was needed in order to remind viewers that this was a science fiction show.

The biggest casualty was Captain Pike, played by movie star Jeffrey Hunter. The actor was allegedly released from his contract after Roddenberry found most of his demands unacceptable. In retrospective, Hunter’s departure was the best thing that ever happened to the show. As good as Hunter is, I don’t think Hunter’s world-weary Pike would have worked well within Roddenberry’s optimism. Hunter died a few years later anyway, so his exit seems almost like an act of fate.

However, most of the things that Trekkies love about the show are here. Composer Alexander Courage’s (The Left Handed Gun and Day of the Outlaw) memorable theme helps establish an atmosphere of adventure and wonder. The visual effects, costumes and sets suffered little change (Matt Jefferies designed the Enterprise).

Conclusions & Final Thoughts:

Beautifully filmed by Oscar-nominated cameraman William E. Snyder (Jolson Sings Again and The Loves of Carmen) at Desilu Studios, The Cage still stands tall among other giants of science fiction and television. Guest stars: Susan Oliver (The Caretakers) and Jon Jon Lormer (Creepshow). Color, 64 minutes.


10 responses to “Star Trek (The Original Series): The Cage (Unaired Pilot)

  1. Going back to your review of “The Menagerie”: this same problem plagued Roddenberry’s second series attempt with Genesis II. The “Kirk” of that series was Alex Cord (someone told me: the “lookalike” John Beck was in the running; I never dug into that to see if that factoid on the show, is true). Anyway, the network found Cord to be too “brooding” and “moody,” like Hunter’s Pike. So, the series was retooled with John Saxon — and a more “emotional” take, like Kirk, came to be. That second retool was called Planet Earth . . . the third crack was Strange New World. You can see “Star Trek” all over those three TV Movie pilots. As for the “too cerebral”: While I didn’t grasp some of it in my youth, I enjoyed the “continuation” cartoon on Saturdays, but it was far from kids fare and got canned for being too cerebral for Saturday mornings.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Roddenberry’s “cerebral” approach probably got him fired from the ST movies. Mind you, I think Motion Picture is underrated, but truth be told, Roddenberry’s overly-solemn style prevented the franchise from growing.


      • I always felt bad for Shanter and the cast, when the Star Wars-inspired greed kicked in and the original plans for a new series was canned for the film. That series reboot would have lasted as long as TNG.

        Liked by 1 person

          • Oh, really? That I did not know: Nimoy refused the series? What a missed opportunity: imagine Kirk — in TNG’s best story arc — going against the Borg. But with that Intel, you’re right: at least Nimoy came back when it all went theatrical.

            Liked by 1 person

            • Apparently, it was a miscommunication issue. Nimoy had written a book called “I Am Not Spock,” which gave the impression that he was done with ST (not true). They did offer him a few guest appearances, but Nimoy felt insulted and decided to move on. Plus Nimoy was still bitter about Paramount’s refusal to pay him (or any of the other actors) royalties for using his image in all sorts of toys and products. The Motion Picture wasn’t going to feature Spock either, but when director Robert Wise came aboard he convinced the studio to hire Nimoy. The actor and studio came to an agreement over the royalties, and the rest is history.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s